Investing in a Roth 401k: 5 Reasons Why I’m All In

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

investing in a Roth 401kMy employer offers some amazing benefits. If you have a child, they’ll send you a rocking chair. If you buy a bicycle, they’ll reimburse $100 of the purchase. If you buy a fuel efficient vehicle, they’ll give you $500. And, I recently discovered that they also offer the Roth 401(k) as an investment option, which could be huge for someone’s financial future.

The Roth 401(k) has been around since 2006 and is finally starting to gain traction in the investment community. The Roth 401(k) acts exactly like a Roth IRA in the sense that investors put in after-tax money and can withdraw the funds at a later date tax-free. In my opinion, investing in a Roth 401k is a better option than the traditional 401k.

5 Reasons Why I’m Investing in a Roth 401k Instead of the Traditional 401k

When I first started working at my place of employment, I almost immediately began setting aside 6% of my earnings toward the traditional 401k that they had available. In addition to my 6%, they agreed to match 3% and also contribute an additional 4% whether I was investing in their 401k or not (like I said before, they have amazing benefits). I’m definitely glad that I started investing early, but now that I’ve dug into the numbers and ran the calculations, I wish that I would have started investing in a Roth 401k instead.

1) I Can Afford the Tax Hit Today

At this moment, I live on approximately 25% of my after-tax income. Paying the tax on my investments really isn’t that big of an issue, so why not start investing in a Roth 401k and just take care of it now? I don’t have a crystal ball for the future, and even though I am investing responsibly for my retirement years, there’s still that chance that I won’t have that much money when it comes time for me to retire (since as you know, there’s no guarantee that the market will continue to rise as it has in years passed).

If this becomes my reality, then it would be extremely nice to avoid the tax man with my investment withdrawals. If I avoid the tax now (by investing in a traditional 401k), then my hunk of money at the end of life would be worth far less than the face value since I’ll be taxed on each withdrawal. If I truly needed the money, this certainly would not be cool.

2) I Don’t Have to Worry About Large Earnings in the Future

Liz and I were chatting the other night and I mentioned that it sure would be nice to have a tax free withdrawal if we have millions of dollars in the future and want to live large. She looked at me with a smirk, “Millions, huh?” – almost like it was impossible. Naturally, I had to prove it to her (and myself) that since we started investing early, millions of dollars is certainly not out of the question.

If I were to invest $750 a month from this point on and earned an average of 8% each year, my nest egg would grow to  $3.5 million by my 69th birthday. It sure would be nice to live large and withdraw $200,000 a year without worrying about the government taking 40% of it. By investing in a Roth 401k, that’s entirely possible.

investing in a roth 401k

3) Taxes Will Likely Be Higher in 30 Years

Some people think that taxes will go unchanged for the next 30 years. Others think that tax rates will actually decrease. I, on the other hand, think that income tax rates will almost certainly rise in the future. The main reason for my belief is the national debt. Not only does it continue to rise by the second, but our government is doing nothing to counter this issue.

This year alone our nation is running a $493 billion deficit, meaning that we’re consciously spending $493 billion more than we’re budgeted to earn. The debts are larger than our yearly GDP, and the income isn’t even close to enough to pay it down. The only way I see this getting under control is with an increase to the income tax percentages in the future. If I’m right, then it would make a ton of sense to be investing in a Roth 401k now when tax rates are low.

investing in a roth 401k

4) Amazing for Estate Planning Purposes

The average investor won’t ever have to worry about this, but if you’re an avid investor and started when you were young, then you’ll likely retire with millions of dollars and possibly some additional income sources as well, which means there really may not be any reason for you to withdraw money from your 401k. Instead, perhaps you’d like to will the money to your children, grandchildren, or to a worthwhile charity after you pass. But, before you get too far ahead of yourself on this one, understand that with a traditional IRA or 401k, you’ll be required to make a minimum distribution out of your investment account at age 70 1/2.

As you can see in the IRS form below, at age 70 1/2 you must take that first distribution, which equates to approximately 3.6% of your retirement fund. In the next year, you’ll have to remove another 3.8%, and then 3.9% the year after. By age 90, you’ll be removing 8.8% per year, whether you need the income or not.

investing in a Roth 401k

This forced withdrawal may not seem like a big deal to many of you, but if you want to leave an inheritance for your children or grandchildren, then it’s a huge deal! First of all, once you finally pass on, your inheritance may be much smaller than you wanted it to be. Second, your beneficiaries will have to pay some hefty tax on your gift to them, often up to 40% for a large inheritance.

What if I told you that investing in a Roth 401k or Roth IRA would save you from making a minimum distribution requirement AND that it wouldn’t be taxed when willed to someone else (up to $5,000,000)? It’s absolutely true. According to IRA guru, Ed Slott, a $5,000,000 Roth asset passed onto a grandchild would be worth $400,000,000 by the time they turned 81 years old. Talk about one heck of a nice gift! I’d call that a legacy!

5) The Match Keeps Me Diversified

As I stated earlier, my employer matches my contributions, but the contributions are not matched within the Roth 401k, they are matched within a traditional 401k. This is how almost every company operates as well, which should make your decision to move your contributions quite simple.

By investing in a Roth 401k with your contributions and your company contributing in the traditional 401k, you are covered in all scenarios. If the taxes go up in the future, then awesome, you benefited because you already paid taxes on your Roth 401k fund. If the taxes go down, that’s cool too, because you can then withdraw from your company’s contributions in your traditional 401k and come out ahead. The match in the traditional 401k still keeps me diversified with each passing month that I contribute.

Will these benefits push you to start investing in a Roth 401k? Why or why not?

If you enjoyed this article, Get email updates (It’s Free!)


  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

13 comments to Investing in a Roth 401k: 5 Reasons Why I’m All In

  • Wow, you do get great benefits.

    In Canada we have the equivalent with TFSA and RRSP accouts.

    One thing I always tell people is that if you go the 401k(RRSP) route, you are more than likely going to pay less tax on that money when you take it out. For example, my current tax bracket would tax me at about 35% with my salary but once I retire, my tax bracket will only be 15%. So I’m better off only paying the tax later.

    Having said that, I max out both accounts so it’s not one or the other. You just have to be strategic on how you take the money out in the future.

    Once again, great article!
    Mr.SelfReliance recently posted..Seedling Transplant Day

    • Thanks for the comment, MSR. Why only the 15%? Do you plan on being poor in retirement? For me, I plan to earn more in retirement than I do today because my fund will likely be enormous, which is why I don’t mind paying the tax today.

      • I do plan on retiring “poor”, lol. My goal is to “semi” retire at age 40. That’s why I want my non taxable account full as well. Then I’ll just take out enough from the taxed account to stay in the lower tax bracket. With zero debt and a paid mortgage, that should be more than enough.

        And if my side income makes me enough money to bump me into a higher tax bracket… oh well, I’ll pay the higher taxes. At that point it won’t matter because that’ll be extra money. I’ll also be able to start diverting most of that excess to charity and give back to my community.
        Mr.SelfReliance recently posted..Seedling Transplant Day

        • Retiring early sounds appealing, but I’m not sure I’ll ever be able to pull the trigger on it. There are just so many unknowns with the costs of healthcare, the stock market, and the overall strength of the economy. We’ll see how I feel when I get there, but it would be one mighty big step to ditch the full-time job and go it on my own.

  • Kathy

    Can you also invest in a regular 401K? If so and you can afford to do so, I’d invest in both, even if the employer will only match one. That way, you have RMDs with the regular one starting at age 70 1/2 but you can let the Roth continue growing by not taking distributions.

    • Hi Kathy. The employer match (which can total up to about 10% of my income) ends up in the traditional 401k, which is why I don’t mind putting all of my contribution into the Roth 401k. On top of this, I will be investing in real estate to ensure a true diversification of my investments (I don’t like tying all of my money in the market – to me, this isn’t real diversification).

  • My work doesn’t offer this, but will keep an eye in the future since I now how a private ROTH. But they do match 3% for my 6%(i put in 10% though), then contribute yearly a core 3% off last year’s total pay. I like that one! And I am only part time. Really love some of the other perks you have, like a fuel efficient car rebate! That is sweet! Our hospital offers discount movie tickets etc, but I hate movie theaters lol.
    Dawn recently posted..90 Day Net Worth Report!

    • Sounds like you have some pretty good benefits too considering you are part time! About the Roth 401k – maybe you could ask your benefits department about it. Who knows, there might be something in the works for it and your inquiry is just what the company needs to bring it on board!

  • Paul

    I really hate my 401k/roth. The money is imprisoned in there until you’re ancient. I’m a responsible adult, why does the government have to imprison my money until I’m near death? That distribution chart above looks scary. Look at the age when the distribution can start. Even if you can take it out at 59.5. That’s old. And the carrot to make us do it is the “matching funds.” Pfft…

    But I am with you on the real estate investing. Passive income that’s sheltered with depreciation. If we know how to play that game we would never bother with the 401k/Roth.

    • Hi Paul,

      I’ve found that it’s best to have a hybrid plan. I invest enough in my 401k to become a millionaire in my old years, but in the meantime I’m investing in real estate and other business ventures. If my businesses pan out, I’ll be a very rich man. If they don’t, then I’ll still have plenty of money to survive in my older years, thanks to my 401k.

  • Why do you want to lock up your money? By the time you actually retire and are allowed withdraw money from it they government has changed the rules already a million times.

    • Hi Mika – thanks for commenting! At this moment, I invest 7% of my work income toward my Roth 401k. By doing this, I get the 3% match from the company, and they also contribute another 4% quarterly and close to 3% for the year. This totals up to approximately 17% of my income. Sure, the rules could change, but since I only need 25% of my after-tax income, I can still invest another 68%! Instead of “locking up my money” as you say, I’m actually keeping 68% of it free and invested into other avenues.

      If the market performs as it has historically, then my Roth 401k will grow to more than $3 million, and that doesn’t even count the other 68% that I’ll be investing. I’m kind of rambling here, but does that make sense? Yes, I love the Roth, but I’m not putting all my faith in it. We should all diversify our money into 6-7 different investments – only one of which should be in the stock market! Thanks again for the comment!

  • […] Related: Investing in a Roth 401k: 5 Reasons Why I’m All In […]

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

  

  

  

CommentLuv badge