Skip to content

How to Attract the Best Tenants for a Rental Property

options if you can't sell your house - for rentOkay, so Liz and I bought our rental property at the end of November. We’re starting to see the light at the end of the tunnel for the renovations, so what should we be thinking about next? Getting some bodies into that house that will actually make the monthly rental payments! We want to attract the best tenants possible…

I have quite a few friends that have tried to be landlords, but somehow they kept getting crappy tenants that trashed the home and couldn’t keep up with the rent payments. These are definitely NOT the tenants I want living in our nicely remodeled house.

After getting the lowdown on their experiences, I realized that they were doing many things wrong in the land-lording department. Basically, they were so excited to get a renter in their home that they just picked the first applicant that walked in off the street! Inevitably, they turned out to be terrible and my friends evicted them, but then simply picked the next warm body that showed interest in the rental. This is most certainly not how to attract the best tenants for a rental property.

How to Attract the Best Tenants for a Rental Property

The last thing I want to do is waste my time catering to a bad tenant that fails to pay and destroys our house during their stay. So how can I attract the best tenants for a rental property? I’ve done my homework on this one and have come up with the following methods. Feel free to use them in finding your own quality tenants!

#1. Decide Who Your Ideal Tenant Is

This is the most important step to attract the best tenants for a rental property. After all, if you don’t have an ideal tenant in mind, how will you know if your applicant will be any good?

Our rental is located across from a fantastic park and is two blocks away from a very popular charter school, which makes it an ideal home for a young family with one or two kids. Ideally, the parents should be earning an after-tax income of $3,500 a month (roughly 3x what we’ll be asking for rent).

This house is also located about 7 blocks from a popular college in the area, so we might be interested in having some college students rent out the house as well. This isn’t our most desired scenario, but if we get a quality applicants that prove they can handle the rent, then this would be perfectly acceptable as well.

#2. Market to Your Ideal Tenant

Once you decide who your ideal tenant is, put on your marketing hat and find a way to round up only those people for your house showing. One landlord I spoke with liked to have his house rented out by local female nursing students – so where do you think he advertised? At the college of course!

He teamed up with the housing coordinator at the college and had her mention his place when the nursing students would inquire about housing. Remember, it’s illegal to discriminate against applicants, but that doesn’t mean you can’t market specifically to your dream tenants!

Since our ideal tenant scenario is a young family, marketing is a little trickier. Our options are to:

  • reach out through our social network for quality tenants
  • post advertisements near parks or within parent/child activity venues
  • advertise through Zillow, Trulia, and Craigslist
  • advertise through my company’s online classifieds

#3. Give All the Details Up Front

Less is definitely not more when advertising your property for rent. People don’t want to take the time to call you for clarification, so if you don’t mention that your property has air conditioning, they’re going to assume that your place doesn’t have it.

Here are some important items to put in your listing if you want to attract the best tenants for a rental property:

  • location with specific address
  • # of bedrooms
  • # of bathrooms
  • monthly rent price
  • cable/internet included?
  • application fee
  • deposit amount
  • new renovations
  • when is your property available
  • mention that you’ll be requiring recommendations with the application

#4. Show the House as if You Were Selling It

For whatever reason, many landlords assume that renters are just going to trash their house anyway, so they fail to fix it up enough to attract the best tenants in the first place.

If you want great renters that wish to live in your place for two years or more, then you’re going to have to show your house as if you’re trying to sell it – and for a hefty price tag as well.

Curb appeal is important. A few simple bushes and flowers could really turn your bland house into a looker. And, when they walk in the front door, make sure that that smile stays on their face – especially with the kitchen! Kitchens make or break home sales, and the same is true for rental properties. Don’t spend thousands of dollars to update your kitchen, but at least make sure it’s clean, neat, and functional.

If your marketing techniques pay off, hopefully you’ll have multiple tenants that are interested in your place. Instead of meeting them all individually, hold an open house. This will do two things:

  1. Make them realize that if they want the house, they’ll have to fill out an application – and FAST!
  2. Save yourself tons of time and travel

#5. Show Yourself Well

Many landlords use the first meet and greet to gauge the caliber of their potential renters. What many don’t realize is that the quality tenants are actually sizing up the landlord as well! If you want to attract the best tenants for a rental property, be sure to dress well and be on your best behavior.

#6. Charge an Application Fee

In order to attract the best tenants (and not just every single person that has a vague interest in renting the property), it makes a heck of a lot of sense to charge an application fee. The purpose of the fee is mainly to cover the costs of pulling their credit history, but it will also save you a ton of time by weeding out those that know they probably won’t qualify and therefore really don’t want to spend money to confirm it.

An appropriate amount for an application fee is $25. It’s not so much that it will scare everyone away, but it’s probably not quite enough to cover the expense of the various background checks and your time, but that’s just how it is with this one. A standard rental application can be found here.

#7. Create Your Contract With Your Perfect Tenant in Mind

If you want a non-smoking tenant that has absolutely no pets, then put that in your contract. State that pets are absolutely not allowed on the property and if they wish to smoke, they must do so outside of the house. When you’re forming your contract, do so with your dream tenant in mind. Want an example of a standard rental agreement? You can find it here. Props to for providing many free resources for new landlords like myself.

#8. Perform Background and Credit Checks

If you want to attract the best tenant for your rental property, then you’ll definitely want to perform background and credit checks before handing over the keys.

First, start with their rental history. Don’t bother calling their current landlord (as he might lie about their history to get them out of his rental!), call the prior landlord instead. Ask about how well they kept up the place and how often they paid on time. If everything checks out, move on to verify their income.

It’s very important that your potential tenants actually have enough income to afford the property. As a rule of thumb, your tenants should be bringing home 3 times the amount of your rent each month (after tax) to cover all other debts and living expenses. To check this, simply call the manager that they listed on their application fee, state who you are and what your purpose is for calling (hopefully the tenant told them this was coming), and verify their earnings amount.

Once they pass the first two tests, it’s now time to pull the actual background and credit checks. There are some freebie sites out there, but they might not show all the detail that you’d like to know. Instead of being cheap here and ending up with a poor tenant because you didn’t have visibility to some important information, I’d suggest splurging a bit and learning all there is to know before you hand the keys over and let complete strangers stay in your house.

(For my prospective tenants, we ended up using TransUnion SmartMove. Their prices were reasonable and it was super easy to use and understand.)

#9. Keep Your End of the Bargain

You’ve done your due diligence to attract the best tenant for your rental property. Now you’ve got to continue doing your job well to keep them there! Keep your phone on you at all times to respond to matters quickly. Calls may be plentiful at first since there may be some quirks that need correcting in the house, but they will likely die down as the months pass.

Beyond just being responsive, be sure to perform proper maintenance on the house each year. Study the roof, the windows, and the general upkeep of the entire place. Your tenants will appreciate the maintenance work and it will save you a lot of time and hassle for when they finally do move out.

#10. Offer an Incentive for On-Time Payments

Another way to attract the best tenants for a rental property – and ultimately to keep them around – is to provide some incentive for all of their on-time payments. Heck, I would put it in the contract!

“With 12 consecutive, on-time payments, the tenant will be awarded a 32″ flat screen TV.”

The flat screen will probably cost you $200, but with $12,000 worth of on-time payments, it’s probably worth it! If you’re renting out a place and are looking to attract the best tenants for the property, this is often a great way to get them excited about staying with you!

Are you looking to attract the best tenants for a rental property? What else would you consider doing?

Grow Rich Money


My name is Derek, and I have my Bachelors Degree in Finance from Grand Valley State University. After graduation, I was not able to find a job that fully utilized my degree, but I still had a passion for Finance! So, I decided to focus my passion in the stock market. I studied Cash Flows, Balance Sheets, and Income Statements, put some money into the market and saw a good return on my investment. As satisfying as this was, I still felt that something was missing. I have a passion for Finance, but I also have a passion for people. If you have a willingness to learn, I will continue to teach.


  1. Great post.
    As a small landlord already we have had some of the teneant issues that you mentioned. It can also depend on what time a year that you are trying to fill the vacancy. Sometimes in the early months of the year the tenant pickings are slim and they are moving because “they have to!” Wziting 2-3 months while paying the carrying costs can be very difficult but could be better in the long run.

    We are in the process of purchasing a bungalow that we are going to convert into an up and down duplex to then put on the rental Market in May.

    Good luck with your tenants.

    • Glad you liked the post SS. It sucks, but it sounds like almost every landlord has a few stories of bad tenants. Thanks for the advice on waiting for a bit. If we get bad applicants, I won’t get discouraged and I’ll choose to wait it out.

  2. Wow, Derek, really appreciate how much detail you put in here. That is one thing that really frustrates me with a lot of posts. You get the basics but not much else. This post is a must read for anyone even thinking about becoming a landlord. Great job drilling down to the specifics.

    • I figured I was gathering all the details for myself anyway – I may as well share everything I learned in a single post, right? Glad so many people found it useful.

  3. Nice post. It almost gives me enough confidence to buy a rental property, too!


    • You definitely should! And then you can add to your list of stories! 😉

  4. This is best post I have read on this subject. Derek, you explained everything what is essential in finding new tenant. This article helped me much to make plan how to find new tenants.

    • Glad you liked it Cynthia! I hope many more will feel the same way!

  5. We provide a $25 discount for early payment (prior to the first), and a $45 late fee for anything the 5th or later.

    Our current tenant was a rockstar on early payments for about 11 months, and then switched jobs and has been paying on time or late since (24 month lease).

    With January being a three paycheck month for her, I’m hoping that she’ll manage to get back to the on time payment cycles, but we will have to see.

    • Pretty simple, but it sounds effective! Hopefully she gets back on track after her 3 paycheck month. 😉

  6. Great Post Derek! I have seen the worst of the worst with renters. I will never allow a cat or dog after our horrible experiences. The free TV idea is gold!

    • We’re still debating on the dog. It can be fine, but it can also be terrible! Glad you liked the TV idea! Thanks for the comment, Preston!

    • I would recommend that you not allow pets. My brother-in-law owned a few duplexes. He allowed pets and charged extra for it. It turned out to be more costlier for him in the long run because he would end up ripping out and replacing the carpet every time he had a long-term renter with a pet. If you are going to allow your renters to have pets in the rental home, don’t be shy about charging an extra $100 a month for rental.

      • Thanks for the advice, Kim! We basically decided to refinish all of the hardwood floors (instead of recarpeting) with pets in mind. I think we’ll definitely charge extra for pets though. Maybe $1,200 a month without and an extra $50 per pet on top of that. We’ll also have a weight restriction on the dogs allowed too – something like, under 30lbs I’m thinking.

  7. Bad tenants are the worst. I have been lucky enough to not have to ever evict anyone but im sure it will happen some day.

    One thing to note also is that you should set a credit/background criteria of what you want your tenant to have and stick with it. 640+ credit score, no late payments, etc…

    • Good advice Alexander. Thanks for taking the time to give some details!

  8. You wrote a good article I want to emphasize one more that it’s important to run renters verification if landlord wants to find a reliable tenant. When it comes to managing a rental property, a bad tenant can be worse than an empty property. So, landlords should also take time to put together a complete screening process. You already mentioned background check and credit reports. But renters verification shouldn’t only be limited by these checks. Interview is another important tool as well.

  9. Number 3 is a golden tip. Being upfront with all the details will help attract the best fit who is happy with their choice, which helps create better tenants.

  10. Showing the house as if you were selling it is a quality tip. You definitely want the buyers to see the best possible look.

    • Yup! For sure! And it helps to walk them all through at the same time. HUGE time saver for me, the landlord.

  11. Good to read! We used other’s bad experiences to learn what not to do as well—screening is the biggest factor to make our rentals keep running smoothly!

    • Absolutely! That’s why I don’t trust most rental management companies – they don’t ever seem to screen as well as I would! They’re more interested in getting someone in there immediately so they can recoup their share of the rent. In other words, their thinking seems more short-term than long-term.

Comments are closed for this article!

Related posts